What is the main difference between a company and sole trader in Ireland?

The main difference is liability protection. Limited companies provide personal asset protection while sole traders have unlimited personal liability for business debts. Companies also offer more credibility and tax planning options but require more administration.

Which is better for tax in Ireland - company or sole trader?

For profits over €50,000, limited companies typically offer better tax efficiency through corporation tax at 12.5% and salary/dividend optimization. Sole traders pay income tax at 20-40% plus USC and PRSI on all profits.

Do VAT rules differ between companies and sole traders?

No, VAT registration thresholds and obligations are identical for both structures. Both must register when turnover exceeds €42,500 for services or €85,000 for goods in any 12-month period.

Can I change from sole trader to limited company later?

Yes, but it involves incorporating a new company, transferring assets, potential tax implications, and professional fees of €500-2,000. It's generally easier to choose the right structure from the start.

How much does it cost to set up each business structure?

Sole trader setup costs €0-50 and takes 24-48 hours. Limited company incorporation costs €125-200 and takes 7-10 days through the Companies Registration Office (CRO).

Company vs Sole Trader Ireland: Which to Choose? | PayVat

Quick Decision Matrix

Use this quick assessment to identify which structure suits your situation best.

Choose Sole Trader If:

You want to start trading immediately

Your business has low liability risk

You're a service provider or consultant

You want minimal admin and compliance

Annual turnover likely under €100k

You don't need business credit/loans

Best for: Freelancers, consultants, tradespeople, creative professionals

Choose Limited Company If:

You want limited liability protection

You plan to raise investment or take loans

You'll have employees or partners

You want professional credibility

Annual turnover likely over €100k

You want tax planning flexibility

Best for: Growth businesses, tech startups, retail, manufacturing, professional services

Detailed Comparison

Aspect	Sole Trader	Limited Company
Setup Time	24-48 hours	7-10 days
Setup Cost	€0-50	€125-200
Personal Liability	Unlimited	Limited to shares
Tax on Profits	20-40% income tax	12.5-25% corporation tax
Annual Filings	Tax return only	Annual return + accounts
Business Credibility	Moderate	High
Raising Investment	Very difficult	Straightforward
VAT Registration	Same thresholds	Same thresholds

Understanding Liability

Personal liability is often the deciding factor. Here's what it means in practice.

Sole Trader Liability

Personal Assets at Risk

• Your home, car, and savings
• No separation between business and personal debts
• Creditors can pursue all your assets

When This Matters Most

• Professional services (advice liability)
• Manufacturing or retail (product liability)
• Any business with employees
• High-value contracts or equipment

Limited Company Protection

Your Assets Protected

• Personal assets generally safe
• Liability limited to company shares
• Company debts stay with company

Important Exceptions

• Personal guarantees on loans/leases
• Director wrongful trading
• Fraud or criminal activities
• Some professional negligence claims

Insurance vs Structure

Professional indemnity and public liability insurance can protect sole traders, but company structure provides additional legal separation. Many choose limited companies for peace of mind alone.

Tax Implications

Tax treatment can significantly impact your take-home income, especially as profits grow.

Sole Trader Taxation

Income Tax Rates (2025)

• 20% on first €42,000
• 40% on income above €42,000
• Plus USC (0.5-8%) and PRSI (4%)
• Effective rate: 24-56%

Tax Benefits

• Simple tax return process
• No separate corporate filings
• Access to personal tax credits

Limited Company Taxation

Corporation Tax Rates (2025)

• 12.5% on trading profits
• 25% on passive income
• Director salary: income tax applies
• Dividends: tax efficient extraction

Tax Planning Options

• Salary/dividend optimisation
• Pension contributions up to €115k
• Capital gains relief options

Example: €80,000 Annual Profit

Sole Trader

€43,600

Take-home after tax

Effective rate: 45.5%

Limited Company

€58,000

Take-home optimised

Effective rate: 27.5%

*Example assumes optimal salary/dividend split. Actual results depend on personal circumstances.

VAT Considerations

VAT registration thresholds and obligations are the same for both structures, but timing and strategy may differ.

Registration Thresholds (2025)

€42,500

Services in rolling 12 months

€85,000

Goods in rolling 12 months

Same Rules Apply

Both sole traders and companies must register when turnover exceeds thresholds. Structure choice doesn't affect VAT obligations.

Strategic Differences

Sole Traders

• May delay registration until threshold hit
• Simpler VAT return process
• Less likely to register voluntarily early

Limited Companies

• Often register early for credibility
• Can reclaim VAT on incorporation costs
• Better positioned for B2B contracts

PayVat Advantage

Regardless of structure, PayVat simplifies VAT compliance with automated calculations, ROS integration, and deadline reminders.

Can You Change Later?

Yes, but it's easier to start with the right structure. Here's what changing involves.

Sole Trader → Limited Company

Process

• Incorporate new company
• Transfer business assets
• Close sole trader tax affairs
• Update all contracts and accounts

Considerations

• Potential capital gains tax
• VAT registration transfer
• Customer/supplier notifications
• Professional fees: €500-2,000

Limited Company → Sole Trader

Process

• Liquidate or strike off company
• Extract remaining assets
• Register as sole trader
• Transfer contracts and relationships

Challenges

• More complex and expensive
• Potential tax on asset extraction
• Loss of limited liability
• Professional fees: €1,000-5,000

Key Takeaway

While changing structure is possible, it involves costs, complexity, and potential tax implications. It's usually better to choose the right structure from the start based on your 3-5 year business plan.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Choosing based on tax alone

Liability protection and business credibility often matter more than small tax differences

Ignoring future growth plans

Consider where you'll be in 3-5 years, not just current turnover

Underestimating liability risks

Even low-risk businesses can face unexpected claims or disputes

Forgetting about investment needs

Sole traders struggle to raise finance for growth or expansion

Delaying the decision

Starting as sole trader "temporarily" often leads to costly changes later

Not considering industry norms

Some sectors expect limited companies for credibility and contracts

Ready to Start Your Business?

Whatever structure you choose, PayVat helps with business registration, VAT setup, and ongoing compliance. Get started today.

14-day free trial

Expert guidance

Setup in days

Last updated: August 12, 2025